Friday, September 25, 2009

Jonathan Edwards on libertarian free will

Thanks to Monergism Books for the tip.

Now, the question is, whether ever the soul of man puts for an act of will, while it yet remains in a state of liberty, in that notion of a state of liberty, viz. as implying a state of  indifference; or whether the soul ever exerts and act of choice or preference, while at that very time the will is in perfect equilibrium, not inclining one way more than another. The very putting of the question is sufficient to show the absurdity of the affirmative answer; for how ridiculous would it be for any body to insist that the soul chooses one thing before another, when at the very same instant it is perfectly indifferent with respect to each! This is the same thing as to say, the soul prefers one thing to another, at the very same time that it has no preference. Choice and preference can no more be in a state of indifference, than motion can be in a state of rest, or than the preponderation of the scale of a balance can be in a state of equilibrium.

From The Freedom of the Will.

No comments:

Post a Comment